What You Need to Know
Recent developments in New Jersey and at the federal level indicate that the regulatory and liability landscape for PFAS continues to expand, even as federal regulators reconsider requirements for specific PFAS chemicals.
New Jersey has long been at the forefront of PFAS regulation, being the first state to establish an enforceable drinking water standard for a PFAS compound in 2018 (PFNA), followed by standards for PFOA and PFOS, in 2020. That continued this June, when the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection (“NJDEP”) finalized and formally adopted groundwater and soil remediation standards for several PFAS. More significantly, NJDEP’s rulemaking also expanded the circumstances in which PFAS testing is required during site remediation. Before the amendment, NJDEP’s interim PFAS standards established cleanup levels but did not require PFAS sampling at every remediation site. Instead, PFAS investigation was generally required only where site-specific information indicated that PFAS may be present. The new rule reverses the presumption: PFAS sampling is now required when contaminants in an area of concern are “unknown or not well documented.”
Meanwhile, in August, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit upheld the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”)’s designation of PFOA and PFOS as “hazardous substances” under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (“CERCLA”). The decision, in Chamber of Commerce v. EPA, is significant in New Jersey because it solidifies PFOA and PFOS as hazardous substances under state law and creates a basis for jurisdiction in federal court for cost recovery and contribution claims for remediation costs. As a result of these developments, NJDEP has expanded the circumstances in which remediating parties must look for PFAS, just as site liability for PFOA and PFOS have become firmly situated within both federal and New Jersey laws.
NJDEP Finalizes PFAS Standards and Expands Testing
NJDEP’s June 2026 rulemaking amended its Remediation Standards rules at N.J.A.C. 7:26D to replace interim standards for soil and soil leachate with promulgated standards for PFNA, PFOA, PFOS, GenX chemicals, and methanol, including remediation standards for the ingestion-dermal and migration-to-groundwater pathways.
NJDEP also amended the Ground Water Quality Standards at N.J.A.C. 7:9C to replace the interim groundwater quality criterion for hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid and its ammonium salt, collectively known as GenX chemicals, with a promulgated standard of 0.02 µg/L. Because NJDEP established interim remediation standards for these PFAS in 2022 and an interim groundwater criterion for GenX in 2023, these changes largely move existing numerical requirements into NJDEP’s permanent regulatory framework.
However, a separate amendment to NJDEP’s Technical Requirements for Site Remediation (N.J.A.C. 7:26E), which govern when PFAS must be investigated, has greater practical significance. Before the amendment, the interim PFAS standards did not require PFAS sampling unless the preliminary assessment or other site-specific information indicated that PFAS may be present. Uncertainty about historical contaminants did not, by itself, specifically mandate PFAS investigation.
NJDEP’s 2026 amendment changes that framework. Under N.J.A.C. 7:26E-2.1(c)1ii, NJDEP now requires analysis for PFNA, PFOA, PFOS, GenX and the dioxin 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin when contaminants in an area of concern are “unknown or not well documented.” If so, samples from all environmental media must be analyzed, even without affirmative evidence of historical PFAS use or discharge at the site. In practical terms, uncertainty itself may now trigger PFAS testing.
NJDEP justified its amendment in significant part based on the widespread use and prevalence of PFAS in New Jersey. Nevertheless, the amendment does not impose universal PFAS testing: where available information sufficiently identifies the contaminants associated with an area of concern (AOC), NJDEP’s amendment would appear not to require PFAS investigation.
LSRP Professional Judgment and “Late-Stage Discovery”
The expanded requirement generated significant public comment when the rule was proposed. Commenters argued that Licensed Site Remediation Professionals (LSRPs) already evaluate site history to determine which contaminants may reasonably be present and that requiring PFAS analysis based on gaps in the historical record could substitute professional judgment with a prescriptive requirement for testing. Commenters also noted that PFAS are widespread, so that testing could identify PFAS without evidence of a site-related discharge and lead an LSRP to investigate off-site sources or anthropogenic background not generally required by NJDEP’s site remediation rules. Other commenters raised concerns that the new requirement may introduce PFAS obligations during the late stage of site remedial activities. Such late-stage discovery, they contended, could prevent compliance with mandatory timeframes or prolong site redevelopment.
The comments highlight NJDEP’s policy choices underlying its amendment. The prior framework placed greater weight on site-specific evidence and LSRP judgment in determining whether PFAS should be investigated. Given the widespread use and contamination of PFAS in New Jersey, NJDEP concluded that the upfront costs of testing where historical information is incomplete are justified by the risk of greater costs and delays from discovering PFAS later. According to NJDEP, the amendment also preserves the LSRPs professional judgment in applying the documented lines of evidence to determine whether PFAS contaminants associated with an AOC are “unknown or not well documented.” Once that condition is satisfied, however, the Department asserted that PFAS cannot be excluded from the required analytical suite simply because they are considered unlikely to be present.
PFOA and PFOS Remain Hazardous Substances Under CERCLA
The consequences of finding PFOA or PFOS have also become clearer following an important federal court decision. In Chamber of Commerce of the United States v. EPA, No. 24-1193 (D.C. Cir. Aug. 18, 2026), the D.C. Circuit rejected challenges by seven industry groups to EPA’s 2024 rule designating PFOA and PFOS as hazardous substances under CERCLA.
Petitioners argued, among other things, that CERCLA permits EPA to designate a hazardous substance only when a release will actually result in substantial danger. The court disagreed. CERCLA, it held, authorizes EPA to designate substances that, when released, “may present substantial danger” to public health, welfare, or the environment. The court concluded that the statute merely requires the possibility – not certainty – of substantial danger. The court also rejected challenges to EPA’s consideration of the rule’s costs and benefits.
The decision leaves intact significant CERCLA consequences. PFOA and PFOS can serve as the basis for EPA-compelled response actions, cost-recovery claims, and contribution actions. Liability under CERCLA's strict, joint-and-several liability framework may extend not only to PFAS manufacturers, but to entities throughout the PFAS product stream, including current or former facility operators, waste haulers, recyclers and others who received or handled materials containing PFOA or PFOS.
Although New Jersey has already designated PFOA and PFOS as hazardous substances under state law, that status is now cemented insofar hazardous substances designated by EPA pursuant to CERCLA also become hazardous substances in New Jersey pursuant to the New Jersey Spill Compensation and Control Act (Spill Act), N.J.S.A. 58:10-23.11b. Perhaps more significantly, the decision now gives responsible parties the ability to pursue – and be subject to – claims for cost recovery and contribution arising from PFOA or PFOS site contamination both in state court under the Spill Act and federal court under CERCLA.
Why These Developments Matter
The interaction between these developments makes NJDEP’s expanded testing requirement particularly consequential. A party may now be required to analyze for PFOA and PFOS because historical information concerning an AOC is incomplete – even without evidence that PFAS were used or discharged there. If testing identifies PFOA or PFOS, the discovery potentially implicates New Jersey’s remediation standards and the liability frameworks of both CERCLA and the Spill Act.
This increases the importance of environmental due diligence and preliminary assessments. Buyers, sellers and remediating parties should consider not only whether there is evidence of historical PFAS use, but whether the historical record sufficiently identifies contaminants associated with each AOC. A thorough preliminary assessment documenting historical operations, raw materials, products, waste streams and potential discharges may provide the lines of evidence necessary for an LSRP to conclude that contaminants are sufficiently known and documented. Conversely, gaps in that record could trigger broader testing. Better historical information may therefore reduce the need for broader environmental testing – and the potential liabilities that can follow from unexpected PFAS discoveries.
EPA Reconsiders Other Federal PFAS Requirements
The D.C. Circuit decision affirming EPA’s designation of PFOA and PFOS as hazardous substances comes as EPA takes a more lenient approach to other aspects of PFAS regulation. In May, EPA proposed extending the time for qualifying water systems to comply with federal drinking water standards for PFOA and PFOS, including the maximum contaminant level of 4 parts per trillion (ppt) for each, by two years to 2031. At the same time, EPA proposed rescinding drinking water regulations for PFHxS, PFNA and GenX chemicals, as well as the Hazard Index applicable to mixtures containing those compounds and PFBS. The comment periods and public hearings for these rules are now closed and EPA is considering whether to pursue the rulemaking.
In New Jersey, the Safe Drinking Water Act Rules, N.J.A.C. 7:10-5.1, adopt and incorporate the current federal PFAS standards as enforceable state requirements. Because the federal PFAS standards are lower than those set by New Jersey, the state must adopt the federal standards and is working to do so. When promulgated, those state standards, in turn, will become the minimum Ground Water Quality Standards for PFAS constituents in state groundwater remediation, N.J.A.C. 7:9C-1.7(c) and (d); N.J.A.C. 7:26D-2.2, and the compliance requirements in New Jersey Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NJPDES) discharge to ground water program permits, N.J.A.C. 7:14A et seq.
EPA’s rule proposals are significant in New Jersey. For several PFAS, the rollbacks proposed by EPA would leave in place New Jersey’s higher standards for drinking water and groundwater and higher discharge limits under NJPDES permits. The stricter standards for PFOA and PFOS would not become enforceable until 2031. For PFNA, the originally proposed stricter standard would not go into effect. As to GenX chemicals, an EPA rollback would leave in place the state’s Ground Water Quality Standard of 0.02 µg/L adopted in June, but remove the enforceable standard for drinking water. Finally, as to PFHxS and PFAS mixtures regulated under the EPA’s Hazard Index, EPA’s rescission of the current federal standards would mean that those PFAS now regulated under federal law would no longer be regulated in New Jersey. Only if NJDEP affirmatively promulgates new rules that set standards “no less stringent” than the rescinded federal standards, as it may do pursuant to its state primacy under the federal Safe Drinking Water Act, would New Jersey regulations reflect the current standards for PFAS under federal law. NJDEP might, for example, adopt compliance dates for PFOA or PFOS sooner than 2031 or adopt enforceable standards for PFHxS or for PFAS mixtures.
Looking Ahead
The central PFAS question is increasingly not whether PFAS will be regulated, as regulation of PFAS is now well established at the state and federal levels, but which PFAS, under which regulatory programs, and what liabilities will follow when they are discovered. For New Jersey remediation projects, NJDEP’s 2026 rule changes the consequences of uncertainty by expressly requiring PFAS analysis when contaminants are unknown or not well documented. For PFOA and PFOS, that expanded testing requirement now intersects with both CERCLA and the Spill Act.
New Jersey, furthermore, continues to evaluate broader PFAS regulation. In April 2026, NJDEP completed a legislatively mandated assessment of the feasibility of regulating PFAS in drinking water. Whereas NJDEP concluded that class-based regulation of PFAS is currently not feasible due to analytical and treatment constraints, it stated that enforceable drinking water standards could be developed for PFAS in subclasses or mixtures. EPA has taken that approach in promulgating its Hazard Index for four PFAS, as discussed above, and other states have set enforceable standards for PFAS mixtures as well. Although NJDEP did not specify which PFAS subclasses or mixtures would be appropriate for regulation in New Jersey, it set forth various considerations for doing so. This may be a signal that New Jersey will move toward cumulative, class-based drinking water standards that could reshape compliance obligations for manufacturers, water utilities, and industrial facilities operating in or discharging into the state.
These developments also occur against the backdrop of New Jersey’s aggressive PFAS enforcement efforts. In August 2026, a federal court approved settlements totaling more than $2.5 billion among New Jersey and 3M, DuPont, Chemours, Corteva and related entities concerning PFAS contamination. The settlement requires the full remediation of PFAS and other contaminants at four industrial sites in New Jersey, regardless of cost, and the establishment of funding sources of up to $1.2 billion (and an additional $475 million reserve fund). The state will use the proceeds of the settlement to fund capital upgrades to treat PFAS, provide financial assistance for PFAS investigation and remediation at fire training academies and airports, and restore natural resources near the four sites, among other things. The magnitude of those settlements, NJDEP’s expanded remediation requirements, and the D.C. Circuit’s confirmation of EPA’s CERCLA authority reinforce that, notwithstanding relaxation of particular federal policies, PFAS will remain a significant source of regulatory obligations and environmental liability in New Jersey.
For more information, please contact the author, Mihir Desai, or any attorney in Riker Danzig's Environmental Practice Group.
|